If Your AI Writes Like Everyone’s AI, Who Wins?
Why AI multiplies your best sellers and makes the rest sound the same
Alternative titles: “AI Levels the Playing Field. Downward.” · “The 100x Seller and the Squeezed Middle”
Every AI vendor makes the same promise: AI will turn every seller into your top seller. In complex B2B, I believe the opposite will happen. AI will make your best sellers dramatically better. And it will make your average sellers sound exactly like your competitor’s average sellers.
The study everyone quotes, and what it really says
The best-known evidence is a 2023 study by Brynjolfsson, Li and Raymond (Generative AI at Work, NBER). Across more than 5,000 customer support agents, an AI assistant raised productivity by 14% on average and by around 34% for novice and lower-skilled agents. The most experienced agents gained very little.
Many people conclude: AI lifts the bottom. That is true for routine work, where the best answer already exists and can be learned from the best people.
Complex B2B selling is not that work. There is no single best answer for a buying group of a dozen people with different agendas. There, AI does something else. It hands everyone the same raw material. What happens next depends on judgment, insight and nerve, and those are not evenly spread.
Meet the 100x seller
Give your best seller a research agent and she walks into every meeting with a sharper point of view than the buyer’s own team. Give her a drafting agent and she spends the saved hours on the CFO conversation nobody else dares to have.
Top performers use AI to go deeper. They were already ten times more effective than average. With AI, that gap can grow a lot wider.
Meet the squeezed middle
The average seller uses the same tools to do more of the same. More emails. More sequences. More “personalised” messages generated from the same LinkedIn profile, by the same models your competitors use. The result is noise at scale.
We already had a sameness problem before AI. In Wynter’s June 2026 research, B2B marketers scored 1.86 out of 5 when matching value propositions to brands with the names removed (pure guessing scores 1.0), and 64% of B2B buyers said it is hard to tell vendors apart from their websites. AI-generated outreach makes this worse, not better. If everyone’s AI writes like everyone’s AI, nobody is memorable.
Middle performers who only use AI for volume are in a losing position. That is not only their fault. Helping them change what they contribute is leadership’s job.
What AI can’t copy
- Reading the room. Noticing that the CFO went quiet when the timeline came up, and asking why.
- Building consensus. Forrester counts around 13 people in a typical B2B buying decision. Getting them to agree is the job.
- Insight with courage. Telling a customer something they don’t want to hear, backed by proof.
- Making your champion a hero. That hero will sell for you when you are not in the room.
None of these are soft skills. In an AI world they are hard currency. And all of them can be trained.
Don’t automate the conversation. Automate everything around it.
My rule of thumb: AI should free up time from preparation and admin, and every freed hour goes back into the conversation with the customer. If AI saves your team five hours a week and they spend it sending more emails, you have bought nothing.
Call to action for sales leaders
- Find out how your top performers use AI differently from the middle. Make that the playbook, not the vendor’s default settings.
- Reinvest the saved time in what AI can’t copy: discovery, reading the room, building consensus.
- Rethink pay and career paths for the sellers who create outsized value, and give the middle a real path to get there.
AI makes strong human skills worth more, not less. The playing field is levelling. The only question is whether your team is standing on the high side.
Go deeper. Reading the room, standing out and asking the question nobody else asks are skills you can train. See Emotional Intelligence to increase your effectiveness in sales, Storytelling and memorable messaging to stand out and Strategic questioning to uncover true buying drivers in my 2ENGAGE Training Catalogue.
This is blog 1 of 4 in my series on AI in B2B sales, originally published on 2engage.nl.